Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Skeptasmic's avatar

Hi. Sorry, my graph was a rather half-assed attempt to quickly make a visual, and I wasn't expecting anyone to pay much attention to it. I just quickly took an existing spreadsheet and got excel to generate a quick graph based on the dates. The original intent of the spreadsheet was to have a list to write the chancery of each diocese and actually find out which claimed Eucharistic Miracles are approved by the bishop. If you want the list I used, there should be a copy on my backup at home from September that would be pretty close to the time I made it. Because the list is a work in progress my current version won't match, but might be more useful to you. It's a bit of a mess though.

The spreadsheet was created by jotting down information as I stumble across it, so it's certainly not the most organized process. It includes all of the EMW list (the one you are calling Acutis's list), except I removed ones that have nothing to do with the Eucharist, as you did. I can't remember if I had gone through the "saints" portion of the list at that time, so those may have been missing. It also includes some from previous versions of that project by Mrs. Acutis and Mr. Meloni, links people have sent me, a few books and papers on the history of Serratia marcasens and desecration of the host libel, and books I've read chasing down the sources of other claimed miracles, which I do in a fairly haphazard manner.

For example, I noted that most of the books on desecration of the host libel state that there were no cases before the 13th century, so I decided to look into the bloody ones EMW shows as earlier than that date. So I started looking at Trani, because that's the earliest bloody one after Lanciano, which I already knew there's no early records was. I traced down the source (easier said than done, they got both the title and the author's name wrong, but it's still better than most of them that have no citations at all) read the book, and found that he has 19 more claimed Eucharistic Miracles in there. So I wrote down the date and the city for the one that has one. One of the others is recognizably Paris, though it doesn't specify. Most of the others are clearly not duplicates, but none had both a date and a location, so I couldn't add them to the list.

So yeah. It's not a great procedure for gathering statistics. Inherently if I'm reading a book written in the 16th century any miracles it mentions are going to be older than that. But I don't really have a better solution. Ideally I would use only the ones approved by the Church, but the whole reason my spreadsheet exists is that that information isn't available.

At the time, my intent was to show the drop off at the Protestant Reformation. I wasn't paying attention to the modern period. There has unquestionably been an uptick in Eucharistic miracle claims since 1972 when leaving wafers soaking in water for weeks became common. The Church is, wisely, generally not publicizing them. For example there are 25 in this paper alone https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40042646/ , and I can't match any of them to a known case. I expect that will continue until the Church either declares that the Real Presence ceases within a few hours after the wafer is placed in water (which would presumably nullify all of the claims that occurred later) or decides that placing them in water and letting them slowly rot is not a respectful way to dispose of them. I can't honestly imagine the current protocol persisting. I've spent a lot of time watching wet wafers rot, and imagining that they could be Jesus's living flesh slowly decaying is a pretty disturbing image.

There has also been an uptick in other claims, and I'm sure Acutis's canonization will inspire plenty of frauds. So I certainly expect there will be an increase, I just don't think many will survive scrutiny.

I feel like I've seen some references to multiplying hosts in the middle ages somewhere, but it doesn't look like I wrote it down. Possibly "Miracles and the Mediaeval Mind" by Benedicta Ward, I think I read that before I started the spreadsheet.

The other popular category you're missing from the Middle Ages is death-by-Eucharist. Those weren't on the EMW list, presumably because they're unpalatable for a modern audience, but back then it was believed that God would often strike people dead for taking the Eucharist unworthily, and there are lots of really gory stories, usually involving Eucharists bursting out of people's throats as they swallowed.

As far as location goes, I think every book I've read on the subject has agreed that the Rhine Valley in Germany was the hotbed. It's said that practically every parish had a bloody wafer at one point. I've actually been wondering why none of them are on the EMW list. Most of them were desecration of the host libel cases, but they have Brussels on there. My guess is that the social and legal situation after World War II made the Church clamp down on these stories, and they're a little better suppressed there than in other areas.

One book I read noted that Italy had surprisingly few cases that accused Jewish people, so it's possible that as a result more stories survived to the modern day. But your main source was also written by Italians, at a time when translating foreign languages was more difficult, and their procedure was as haphazard as mine. I suspect that biases the results. Although, as you note, it wouldn't be surprising if Italy did have a lot of cases.

Otto the Renunciant's avatar

It seems to me that the increase in recent miracles is related to what is actually very fertile ground despite initial appearances. Religiosity is down, yes, but that is a result of doubt due to science, and some modern cognitive theories suggest that doubt can only occur when someone already has belief, meaning there is a bias towards confirmatory evidence despite it looking on the surface like the opposite is true. If there is a dynamic of decreased religiosity due to doubt that arises from increased belief in science, then once you get the first scientifically-"confirmed" Eucharistic miracle, lots of people who are doubting would see that as a way to reconcile their cognitive dissonance, and you'd see a cascade of new miracles that fall into that same type. And that's what we see: a lot of miracles that happen to be of the type that was first scientifically "confirmed" and is also able to be confirmed with the most robust scientific reasoning.

7 more comments...

Ready for more?